Water Bath vs Pressure Canning: Which Foods Need Which
The food's acidity decides the method. High-acid foods (pH 4.6 or lower) can be processed in a boiling-water bath. Low-acid foods (above pH 4.6) must be processed in a pressure canner, because only the higher temperature inside a pressure canner destroys the spores of Clostridium botulinum.
Why the method matters
Boiling water at sea level reaches 212 °F (100 °C). That is enough to destroy moulds, yeasts and most bacteria in an acidic food, where botulism spores cannot grow anyway. In a low-acid food the spores survive boiling and can produce toxin in the sealed jar. A pressure canner at the tested pressure reaches about 240 °F (116 °C), the temperature tested processes rely on for low-acid foods. No length of time in a water bath makes up for it.
Which common foods go where
| Boiling-water bath (high-acid) | Pressure canner (low-acid) |
|---|---|
| Most fruits: peaches, pears, apples, applesauce, berries | Vegetables: green beans, corn, carrots, beets, potatoes |
| Jams, jellies and fruit butters | Meat, poultry and seafood |
| Pickles and relishes made with a tested vinegar recipe | Stocks and broths |
| Fruit juices such as apple and grape | Soups, stews and chili (with a tested recipe) |
| Tomatoes, with added acid (bottled lemon juice or citric acid) in every jar | Dried beans and peas |
Tomatoes sit on the line between the two, which is why tested tomato processes call for added acid in every jar. Pickling moves a low-acid vegetable to the water-bath side only when a tested recipe sets the vinegar strength and amount; never cut the vinegar.
Altitude changes both methods
Water boils at a lower temperature as you go up. For a water bath, tested recipes add processing time at higher altitudes. For a pressure canner, they raise the pressure: a dial gauge goes up in steps, and a weighted gauge typically moves from 10 to 15 pounds above 1,000 feet. Each food's own table says how much; use the one for your food and jar size. The canning times by altitude chart shows the published times and pressures for each food, band by band.
Jar size and tested processes
A process is tested for specific jar sizes. A smaller jar can use the time for the next larger tested size, never the other way round, and a size with no tested process (half-gallons for almost everything) has no safe time at all.
Doing this in Putby
Putby's Safety tab and Log a batch screen read the same tested table: type a food and it shows the method, the altitude-adjusted time or pressure, the headspace and the source. Low-acid foods always route to pressure, and when no tested process covers a food, jar size or altitude, Putby says so and shows no number. The reference is free and works in a browser at putby.adelyons.com, no sign-in.
Look up the tested process
Putby shows the tested method, time or pressure and headspace for your altitude, with its source, and never invents a number.
More guides: Home & hobby · all Adelyons guides